Metacognition and giftedness – what teachers need to know

Gifted students often possess exceptional learning abilities and a natural curiosity. But what truly sets them apart from their peers? Research highlights the crucial role of metacognition, the ability to think about one's own thinking, in their learning experiences and performance. For educators, understanding and fostering metacognition in gifted students provides opportunities to fully unlock their potential.

What is metacognition?

Metacognition is often described as "thinking about thinking" and refers to the awareness and control of one’s own thought processes. It includes two important aspects that complement each other. First, there is metacognitive knowledge, which means understanding how one learns, which strategies are effective, and how these strategies can be applied to specific tasks. For example, knowing that repetition and summarizing can be effective for retaining information. Second, there are metacognitive skills, which refer to the ability to make plans, monitor progress, and adjust strategies when needed (Cheng, 1993). These skills are evident when a student decides to spend more time on a difficult task or changes their approach if the initial strategy isn’t working.

A concrete example of this is a student who is aware that they struggle with detail-oriented reading (metacognitive knowledge). To address this issue, they decide to take notes and highlight key points while reading a text (metacognitive skill). Through this process, they remain aware of their own learning needs and adjust their approach to achieve the desired outcome. This type of self-awareness and the ability to take action are at the core of metacognitive learning. It enables students to not only learn more effectively but also become more resilient when facing challenges and setbacks in the learning process.

Why is metacognition crucial for gifted students?

Metacognition plays a crucial role in the academic success of gifted students because it helps them effectively utilize their intellectual abilities. While gifted students often demonstrate an accelerated understanding of abstract concepts and excellent problem-solving skills, research by Tibken et al. (2021) shows that these skills alone are not enough. Metacognitive skills, such as monitoring one’s own progress and adjusting strategies, are just as important for overcoming challenges and successfully tackling complex tasks.

This importance becomes clear in situations where the natural talent of gifted students is not enough on its own. For example, consider a student who is used to solving complex math problems quickly without much effort. When they suddenly encounter a challenging problem that cannot be solved with standard strategies, a lack of metacognitive skills may cause them to get stuck. On the other hand, a student with strong metacognitive skills will review their strategy, ask questions like "What isn't working here?", and try a new approach, such as breaking the problem down into smaller steps or consulting additional resources.

Additionally, metacognition helps gifted students learn how to learn, a skill essential for long-term success. Many gifted students experience few challenges in elementary school and therefore may not always develop the skills to study effectively or cope with failure. When they encounter more difficult tasks in high school or university, they may struggle to adjust their usual approach. Metacognitive skills, such as reflecting on what works and what doesn’t and planning the next steps, can help them navigate these challenges and become more resilient in their learning process.

Another important point is that metacognition also plays a role in preventing underachievement, a common issue among gifted students. Tibken et al. (2021) highlight that underachievement is often associated with a lack of metacognitive skills. Students who don't know how to monitor or regulate their learning are at greater risk of falling short of their potential. For example, imagine a gifted student struggling with time management and consistently spending too little time on complex tasks. By developing metacognitive skills, such as estimating the time needed for a task and monitoring progress, this student can learn to work more effectively and achieve better results.

In short, metacognition is not only a tool for gifted students to tackle complex academic challenges, but also an essential skill for continuously improving themselves and succeeding in increasingly complex environments. It is the key that helps them fully realize their potential, now and in the future.

Metacognitive training in practice

Research by Sheppard and Kanevsky (1999) shows that training in metacognitive skills has significant positive effects, especially when applied in classrooms with like-minded students. Gifted students who participated in metacognitive training in homogeneous groups—where all students had a similar high intellectual level—demonstrated more complex and creative thinking models after the training than their peers in heterogeneous groups, where students of different intellectual levels collaborated. This difference was evident in how these students analyzed problems, visualized their thought processes, and developed innovative solutions.

One example of such training was the use of a "thinking machine" analogy, where students were asked to compare their own thinking process to a machine and describe how it functioned. Students in homogeneous groups developed more detailed, structured, and original machine analogies. These thought models not only reflected a greater understanding of the complexity of their own thinking processes, but also an improved ability to adapt their strategies to different tasks. Furthermore, these students spontaneously built upon their peers' ideas in the group, further stimulating their creative growth.

In contrast, in heterogeneous groups, students were often more reserved and conforming. They were less likely to share in-depth or creative insights, possibly because they felt less comfortable in an environment with peers of varying levels. This highlights the importance of an environment where gifted students feel free to explore their potential without being held back by differences in abilities within the group.

The findings of Sheppard and Kanevsky suggest that a challenging environment with peers functioning at the same intellectual level can be a catalyst for metacognitive growth. This does not mean that heterogeneous groups are not valuable, but it indicates that specific training in homogeneous settings can be a powerful tool for helping gifted students further develop their unique thinking abilities. For educators, this offers an important consideration when designing programs for gifted students: carefully grouping students can significantly enhance the effectiveness of metacognitive training.

Practical tips for educators

Integrating metacognitive training into classroom practice provides educators with a powerful way to enhance students' learning. An effective approach starts with introducing reflection exercises. Encourage students to think about their own learning process, for example, by having them write about which strategies worked or didn’t work when preparing for a test. For instance, a student who realizes they spent too much time memorizing details and not enough time understanding the overall concept can use these insights to improve their approach in future assignments. Reflection helps students not only learn better but also recognize and optimize their own learning patterns.

Visual tools are another effective way to promote metacognition. Consider using mind maps or self-made "thinking models" where students visualize their thought processes. For example, a student trying to understand a complex topic like the food chain in biology could create a mind map connecting producers, consumers, and decomposers. These visual representations not only help structure information but also make it easier for students to identify gaps in their understanding.

Differentiation also plays a crucial role in metacognitive training. By forming small, challenging groups where students can learn from each other, educators can create an environment that encourages students to improve their skills. An example of this is a group of students working on a project about climate change, where each student is assigned a specific task that aligns with their strengths. By reflecting on and evaluating their individual contributions, they not only learn from their own processes but also from those of others.

Finally, it is important to systematically monitor students' progress. This can be done using tools such as self-assessments and rubrics, which help students gain insight into how well they are applying their metacognitive skills. For example, after a group project, a student might reflect on questions like, "Did I manage my time well?" or "Did I adjust my approach when something didn't work?" These tools not only help evaluate their current skills but also encourage continuous improvement.

By applying these strategies, educators can create a learning environment that encourages and supports metacognition, helping students not only learn better but also learn how to learn more effectively. This is an investment that benefits them throughout their entire educational journey.

Conclusion

Metacognition plays a crucial role in the success of gifted students. The ability to reflect on and control their own learning processes not only helps them achieve academic goals but also provides tools to tackle challenges outside the classroom. For educators, the key lies in systematically integrating metacognitive strategies into their teaching practices, so students not only learn but also learn how to learn.

References

• Cheng, P.-w. (1993). Metacognition and Giftedness: The State of the Relationship. Gifted Child Quarterly, 37(3), 105-112.
• Sheppard, S., & Kanevsky, L. S. (1999). Nurturing gifted students’ metacognitive awareness: Effects of training in homogeneous and heterogeneous classes. Roeper Review, 21(4), 266-272. doi:10.1080/02783199909553974
• Tibken, C., Richter, T., von der Linden, N., Schmiedeler, S., & Schneider, W. (2021). The role of metacognitive competences in the development of school achievement among gifted adolescents. Child Dev. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13640

Copyright © 2025 Dr. Sabine Sypré – All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reproduced in any form or by any means, whether electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without prior written permission from the author. Sharing online is permitted provided the author is credited and a link to this article is included.